Habermas: That’s fair. Flew: And I don’t think those appearances are an adequate basis for it. In all this, I think one ought to notice that any experiences of claims to what is nowadays called the paranormal—what used to be investigated by what was called psychical research—any claims to the genuineness of such occurrences have to be founded, if they’re to be believed, on an extraordinary amount of evidence. Anything that is conceived to be miraculous falls into this category, because one must approach